Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
I didn't mean this to be a thread initially, but the more I kept finding about the coil pack versions for POST 9/2002 E46, more questions arose, which led me to do more research and i thought i'd post here as a thread for anyone who will be replacing their CPs soon / in the future.
Fist: This info only pertains to the POST 9/2002 E46 cars, which use the newer type of coil packs, which are not held by 2 screws. It is among these newer types that I find some discrepancies as to suggested part numbers by Bosch, BMW and online vendors.
OK. Let's start:
First, the oldest of these types by Bosch, which are also in my car, a 2005 June.
This type has the following Bosch Part No stamped on the CP's hold-down connector: 0 221 504 100
This is what it looks like:
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...63_E65_OEM.jpg
Now, on to the REVISED/UPDATED versions:
At some point, Bosch/BMW revised the CP. I am not sure when this happened, but from the reading I have done, these revisions are supposed to reduce misfires and increase longevity.
Now, Let's see how they're listed at ECS Tuning: (Focus only on the Bosch plugs here - 1st and 3rd in the screenshot):
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b176/nishang/ECS.jpg
As you can see. they list TWO types of Bosch CPs:
1. with The BMW Part no. 1213 171 2219
2. with the BMW Part no. 1213 759 4937
Both those types look pretty much identical and are skinnier, all black, and don't have the boot separate, but looks like it's all one piece, and look like this:
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...L._SL1500_.jpg
Now, I went to Bosch USA parts catalog, and searched CPs for E46:
and this is what I came up with. Note only ONE type is recommended.
(ONLY LOOK AT 2nd LINE, as first line is for PRE 9/2002)
(as you can see by matching BMW No ending with 2219, this is the same as the FIRST type ECS suggests)
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...ang/bosch2.jpg
DETAILED INFO on that plug:
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b176/nishang/b3.jpg
This has Bosch part number: 0 221 504 464 (you can see that on screen shots, and ECS image also shows this number stamped on plug)
Now, if you look at the 2nd screenshot again, you will see that this plus ALSO corresponds to the BMW no. 1213 171 2219 AND
12 13 7 594 938
NOTE: this is NOT the other (2nd) Bosch plug that ECS suggests: THAT one has BMW no. 12 13 7 594 937
So, why is ECS suggesting this CP with BMW Part no -937 for an E46?
I chatted with ECS:
--First I asked what is the difference between their 2 plugs that are recommended; Answer was: "the one ending with BMW no 2219 is a revised plug, and THAT was revised AGAIN, and THAT new one has the BMW no ending with 937"
--(so we have THREE types of plugs for E46 according to him. Old two tone one, and two newer all black types, which look identical)
--He could not answer the question "Why doesn't Bosch suggest this part number for E46"?
I tried finding this Bosch part no. on their catalog, and found that it has the Bosch part no. 0 221 504 470
(and ECS image correctly shows this number stamped on plug).
Here's a comparison of both on the Bosch catalog: (the one on left is what Bosch suggests on their search, the one on right is the 2nd one ECS suggests)
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...hang/b4new.jpg
--Next, I looked online on forums and found that this Bosch plug (Bosch --470 and BMW --937) is recommended for E90 and up cars, and NOT for E46.
--This plug is available online but almost always suggested as NOT for E46, but for E90 and up.
--Then I went to Bosch catalog and entered a 2008 E92 as my car: YEP: The suggested plug was Bosch --470, (BMW --937)
So, again:
why is ECS suggesting this CP with BMW Part no -937 for an E46?
Time for more research: REAL OEM: Here are part numbers suggested for E46:
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...ng/realoem.jpg
!!!! Notice that the BMW part no. 219 (Bosch --464) is listed as ENDED, meaning it was updated/revised.
And lo and behold, what does Real OEM recommend now (see screen shot above)?
The BMW --937 (Bosch --470) !!! ....which is, yep, NOT recommended by Bosch for E46
SO, summary so far:
-REALOEM recommends the Newest Revision (Bosch --470/ BMW --937) as the current CP for E46: (Lists previous revision Bosch 464/BMW 938 as "ENDED")
-ECS recommend BOTH types
-Tischer and Bavauto also recommends Bosch 470/BMW 937
-Bosch catalog recommends ONLY previous revision (Bosch --464 / BMW --219/938)
I only found ONE other place that listed this (newest) Bosch CP number (--470) for E46 (Europarts.com):
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1.../Europarts.jpg
EDIT: Tischer, and Bavauto also recommend Bosch 470 / BMW 937 (Thanks go to member "1972Ford" (bimmerfest) for this info)
Several sites listed this newest revision with the word "Updated version"
PLACES that do NOT suggest this newest revision (Bosch --470 / BMW --937) for E46:
(These places all suggest 2nd revision: Bosch --464 / BMW 219 or 938)
1. Amazon: (has correct image) - see warning that it does NOT fit.
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...mazon%20cp.jpg
2. Turner Motor Sports (has WRONG image - shows the OLDEST type plug) - see part no. highlighted on bottom
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b176/nishang/tms.jpg
3. Autohaus AZ: (see red box warning)
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...044%204938.jpg
SO:
What I have really done is raise questions:
-What's the different between the two newer types ? (Bosch 464/BMW 938 and Bosch 470/BMW 937)
-Is the newest (Bosch 470) really better? what was revised?
-Why does RealOEM and ECS list the newest Bosch CP for our cars ?
(Real OEM ONLY lists the newest revision, previous one is listed as 'ENDED')
-Why doesn't Bosch recommend their newst --470 type for E46? (and Amazon, TMS, Autohaus AZ...)
-Which recommendation can be most accurate/should I choose? :
ECS and Real OEM? or Bosch and all the rest of major online retailers?
And finally: I have seen posts on forums about the newer "one piece - all black" type CPs (464 and 470) not making a SNAP noise or that they don't CLICK into place when installing. Quite by accident, I found this Bosch site:
http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b1...hang/bosch.jpg
Now, if anyone has any feedback or have noticed something I haven't, please comment. I am totally confused by what I have presented above, concerning how different sites/retailers recommend these 2 types of plugs.
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
Yeah it's another BMW part no for the - 470 Bosch part number
Please update on fitment and performance when you install them, if you get a chance.
Thanks !
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
Oh, you have installed them before? That's good to know they will work!
Amazon also has them ( Bosch ) 6 pack shipped ( if you have Amazon prime ) for $179
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
Please post a good clear pic of a CP when you get them - just curious to see if there are any differences from the Bosch part.
What differences do you think exist between the Bosch - 470 and the genuine BMW part that makes the BMW coil pack better ?
I am just trying to get the most accurate info I can for the future; I always thought Bosch makes them for BMW anyway.
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
BMW 937 and 689 are the same part no as Bosch 470
http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/04...e45b8908cd.jpg
And this from FCPeuro makes it even clearer
Shows all 3 part numbers ( BMW 689 and 937 with Bosch 470 which is the same plug Amazon has)
http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/04...ec2e5b0c46.jpg
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
Thanks !
They look identical to the Bosch part no ending with 937, which is what I wants to verify
I bet if you had looked closely at the coil body or the hold down tab, there is a tiny Bosch logo ( NOT wording ) on them somewhere - it looks like an upper case H with the sides curving outward.
At 48k miles I definitely still have the old style factory gray coils in my car and they have the BMW part no but Bosch logo stamped on them ( the above mentioned "H" looking symbol)
-So I think it's safe to assume that Bosch makes them for BMW even now, and list them all together with the BMW part number and their own Bosch part number so 689 (BMW pn) and 937 ( Bosch pn) etc are probably all the same and come up interchangeably depending on where one searches
Of course the ones stamped or boxed with a BMW part number with BMW box will be more costly.
Same with oil filters : BMW dealer has BMW stamped Mann oil filters - exact same thing as a Mann stamped filter that you get from Amazon etc
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
Actually my old style gray bodied factory "BMW " coils even have Bosch lettering and the logo on the area where the hold down tab attaches to : more proof that Bosch is factory and BMW OE
http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/05...ab3a03f170.jpg
Bosch logo on other side
http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/05...986cf836e4.jpg
Would be interesting to see if the OLD factory plugs you took out of your car also have the Bosch on them
- do you still have them by any chance ?
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
I see
But they were over 200k old I thought - idk what's the normal life expectancy of ignition coils is but that seems to be pretty good, and IIRC you said you never had a misfire despite the hesitation in light acceleration...
I also read that some people keep an old spare coil in the car just in case one goes out etc as a precaution - but yours are brand new you should not be needing any replacements soon anyway
But great to hear the new ones are doing well
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
Coil Pack (POST 9/2002) info / descrepancies.
They have red hold down tabs - I wonder if that's why ppl buy them despite the crappy reviews on the web
Sent from my NOT bent iPhone 6 using Tapatalk