Originally Posted by
bullfrogs_M3
I will speak from personal experience from owning both a 2002 E46 M3 and my current 2004 ZHP.
When I first got into the BMW brand, it was with my wife and buying her a 3.0 X5. We loved that thing and at the time I had a clean title heavily modded 270WHP Grand Prix GTP. So I started to do some looking around for a new car and originally found that I really really like the ZHP over the M3. However after test driving a Dinan badged SMG M3, I was sold and ended up buying it that day. The power that an M3 has is absolutely incredible!!! It is raw but checked and subtle (depending on mods of course) but when you want to drive it as a drivers car, it is more than willing to let you drop the hammer and ask if you have anything else to throw at it. I ended doing some subtle mods to the car. JIC Coilovers, UUC Sways, (kept the Dinan mods, exhaust, intakes, software), Euro SMG flash and wheels. This thing was planted, firm in every corner I threw it at and took off like a bat outta hell. BUT..... I was currently driving about 75 miles/day on it for a local job and the miles added up quick in 2 years. That being said, the maintenance cost started to go up and up. Before I threw in the towel I was looking at having to drop 3-4K out of my pocket for a steering issue(it constantly felt like I was on ice on a clear dry summer day) and other internal issues.
Before I threw in the towel I actively started looking at my first choice the ZHP. I was lucky enough to find this one with all my options I set out for (Black, Natural Brown, 6MT, low low mileage). After having owned this car for longer than I have owned any car I have ever had, I can honestly say this is the best thing I have driven, PERIOD. My maintenance costs are reasonable (when i actually DO take it in, which is only twice since i've owned the car) and my mods, while subtle and many are very reasonably priced as well. I couldn't say those two statements at all when I owned the M3, that car commands a higher premium for parts/labor/etc. over the standard E46. This should ABSOLUTELY be what you take into consideration when thinking about the M3. Seriously, find an M3 online, then spec out the list of things you want to do to it, exterior, interior and engine. Then do the same with a non-M3 and compare pricing.
I also really appreciate the insurance aspect of the ZHP over the M3. When I had the M, it was a sports car coupe which drove my insurance up considerably. But with this, it is only classified as a sedan and those additional OEM performance options we have are not taken into consideration (or at least with my insurance buddy).
All said and done:
Pro's for M3:
Power, Power, Power
Instantly recognizable as a performance car. PERIOD
Con's for M3:
Maintenance costs are high (at my time of ownership)
Mod costs are high
Insurance costs are high (depending on age and state of course)
Pro's for ZHP:
Realistic maintenance costs
Realistic modding costs
Realistic Insurance costs
Con's for ZHP:
ummmm.....well I guess the lower HP? I don't know....... I personally would of loved an SMG option (i know I know, people here hate that but I LOVED LOVED LOVED my SMG and felt like a formula 1 driver especially in the twisty mountains we have around Phoenix)