So I tested it using the OBC
Car off 12.2 - 12.3
Car on started at 13.9, then slowly crept up to 14 and 14.2 max.
Car started ok this time - perhaps just a TINY shudder ONCE as idle speed started to settle...
So I guess it's not the battery, huh? (although the AAP guy's tool said 'charging needed')
btw OBC function 2.0 is COOL - gauge test - will post a video shortly...