Thanks Fredo, I'd found that one too. That's a 2006 brochure and mine's a 2005, probably close enough, but

Black it is. Both the mesh grille and the backing piece both seem to be in really good condition. I just snapped the 2 pieces back together and tossed it in with the bumper to bring to the dealer (along with the license plate holder). The amber side reflectors also popped right out without damage