
Originally Posted by
az3579
Both of these methods failed.
It's called a flare wrench, BTW.
i was going to say, maybe you just weren't doing it right...
but then i read on...

Originally Posted by
az3579
Alright, so quick update.
Bruce, when you mentioned vice grips, we tried that at Charlie's place and failed. It turns out, the vice grips were at fault in this case. The ones we used were from Harbor Freight, and it was actually damaging the vice grips as we tried to get the nut loosened.
Today I was visiting my BMW Tech friend at his place and he said "let's check it out". Little did I know I'd have my caliper installed tonight.
He used his SnapOn vice grips and that totally did the trick. That thing grips like a mofo.
nice, glad you got it sorted. and yes, cheap tools do suck sometimes. there are rare exceptions, of course (depends on the tool).
peter
peter
2004 330i ZHP
2005 330iT ZHP
2010 328iT M Sport
2012 128i M Sport